Skip to Content

Sugar Cookie Coffee

This shop has been compensated by Collective Bias, Inc. and its advertiser. All opinions are mine alone. #MyMrCoffeeMoments #CollectiveBias

Sugar Cookie Coffee

Sugar Cookie Coffee – A great holiday drink recipe made with just a few simple ingredients! Tastes just like a sugar cookie!

My favorite part of the holiday season is getting together with friends and family.  It’s a great time to make memories and connect over a cup of coffee.  One of my friends and I have a holiday tradition that revolves around making a holiday-themed coffee drink together and watching a seasonal movie while sipping on our coffees and this year, I decided that we needed to try making sugar cookie coffee! What could be more festive and fun than combining my favorite holiday cookie with coffee?!

To get everything I needed, I popped over to my local Walmart.  My coffee pot was on the fritz so after doing some research, I picked up a Mr. Coffee® Easy Measure coffee maker.  Mr. Coffee® is easy to use, uncomplicated, creates reliable results that you can trust and only they keep it simple to make great coffee, so you can get on with life.

I know that I struggle sometimes to know how much coffee grounds to use and this coffee pot solves the problem! The Color-Coded Measuring System makes it super easy to use the correct amount of coffee grounds and water so that you have consistently great coffee every time.  Plus, it has an Advanced Water Filtration system that helps improve the coffee’s taste by removing impurities and it has a 4-Hour Freshness Indicator that lets you know if it is fresh or not.  It really helps consumers take the guesswork out of making coffee so you can always have delicious, consistent results.


Interested in getting a Mr. Coffee® Easy Measure coffee maker? Hover over the product in the image above!

The Mr. Coffee® Easy Measure 12 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker is the flagship of Mr. Coffee®’s brand refresh with their new Mr. Coffee® innovation items of 2019.  It’s the very first to launch with all of the new designs and messaging.  I think it is super cool to see where they are going as a company!

Some other things that I loved about this coffee maker are the programmable LED display, clean cycle and reminder, and that you can pause the brewing cycle and serve so that you can snag a cup of coffee before the brewing is finished.  If you are like me and try to grab a cup of coffee before it’s done brewing and usually would make a complete mess, than this is the coffee maker for you!

Now to make this sugar cookie coffee recipe, you simply brew the coffee in your Mr. Coffee® Easy Measure coffee maker and make a creamer over the stovetop.  The whole process takes just a few minutes and it can be a great drink to make for a crowd at a holiday party or for yourself! The recipe for the creamer can be doubled, halved, quartered, etc so there is a lot of flexibility there.

Can’t get enough of this sugar cookie coffee recipe? Try these other recipes!

My favorite way to serve this coffee is with a dollop of homemade whipped cream on top and a dash of cinnamon but there are so many different options for what you can do! Enjoy! #NewellHomeRefresh

Yield: 4 Servings

Sugar Cookie Coffee

Sugar Cookie Coffee

Sugar Cookie Coffee - A great holiday drink recipe made with just a few simple ingredients! Tastes just like a sugar cookie!

Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 15 minutes


  • 12 cups coffee (made using Mr. Coffee® Easy Measure coffee maker)
  • 2 cups half-and-half
  • 1/2 cup good quality white chocolate chips
  • 3 tablespoons vanilla syrup
  • 1/2 teaspoon almond extract
  • Whipped cream


  1. Brew coffee according to the instructions for the Mr. Coffee® Easy Measure coffee maker.
  2. While the coffee is brewing, combine half-and-half, white chocolate chips, vanilla syrup, and almond extract in a small saucepan over medium heat. Cook until white chocolate chips melt, stirring regularly.
  3. Pour coffee into mugs and add the sugar cookie creamer to taste. Top with whipped cream.

Never miss a Mildly Meandering recipe

Facebook / Instagram / Pinterest / Twitter

jennifer stewart

Thursday 19th of December 2019

What a great combo! Like drinking my dessert!

Skip to Recipe